Preply and italki charge you in different ways
One expires your unused lessons every 28 days, and bills you 13 times a year rather than 12. The other charges per lesson and stops. Both help centres quoted, both prices converted into the same unit.
I searched "preply vs italki" on 22 August 2026, then "which is better preply or italki 2026" to check. Same page at number 1 both times.
It's on italki.com, bylined "italki Language Learning Team," and it concludes that italki is better. The second result was Preply's version. So the top two answers were the two companies, each grading its own homework.
So take the answer up front. If your schedule moves around, pick italki: you buy one lesson at a time and a bad month costs you nothing.
If you've quit tutoring before because nobody was expecting you, pick Preply. The automatic charge every 28 days is a commitment device, and it works on the people who need one.
The rest is the evidence, including the part that costs you money either way: Preply's cycle is 28 days, so a year is 13 charges. If you want the italki side as a monthly bill, I worked it out here.
italki and Preply both wrote their own comparison
Start with the mechanic a buyer most needs before handing over a card: unscheduled Preply lessons expire at renewal. On italki's page that arrives as a paraphrase, never as a quote from Preply's help centre. There it sits in one flat sentence anybody could have copied.
Then look at the evidence under "Which platform is better for serious language goals?" It's a study about italki, cited by italki. I couldn't reach a primary source, so its number isn't in this post.
Parts of that page are genuinely good, and I want to be fair about it. It runs about 4,300 words, and a long stretch of them summarise Reddit threads about who got burned and how.
That section does real work, and Reddit is closed to my tools entirely, so I won't pretend I found the same threads. Search r/languagelearning for the tutor's name before you book.
I can quote help centres at you; I can't tell you whether a specific teacher cancels.
Worth saying that those quotes carry no permalink, no username and no date, so you can't check them either. The introductions are lopsided too, roughly 145 words for italki against roughly 60 for Preply.
I read the second-place page too, which is Preply's. Its pricing section says both platforms run "$4-$40+ per $40+ per lesson," a sentence nobody proofread.
Preply's own comparison page never mentions Preply's 28-day expiry. I checked all 3,567 words.
So, the method. Both help centres and both pricing pages, quoted directly, with the arithmetic neither company does and a note on what I couldn't verify.
Preply's 28-day cycle means 13 charges a year
Preply's help centre page, dated 17 July 2026, is clear in a way its marketing isn't. The core:
- "A Preply subscription is between you and one tutor. Every 28 days, you are automatically charged for a fixed number of lessons with them."
- "The minimum plan is 4 lessons per cycle."
- "Any lessons not scheduled before the renewal date expire."
- Pause once per billing cycle, for up to 20 days. Cancel "at least 1 day before your next billing date."
That third line is the one, and the load-bearing word is unscheduled. A lesson has to be on a calendar before the renewal date, even if it happens well after. The FAQ at the bottom of the same page says it a second way: "Unscheduled lessons expire at renewal and do not carry over."
Now the arithmetic nobody does, and it's the one that gets you. 28 days isn't a month.
The renewal walks backwards through the calendar all year, and Preply's own example shows it: 1 January, then 29 January, then 26 February. Budget for 12 charges and you'll be billed 13.
A thirteenth minimum plan you didn't plan for. On a $16 tutor, roughly $53. It appears on neither comparison page.
Two other things go unmentioned everywhere I looked. There's no escape hatch: "Standalone one-time lesson purchases are not available, including through customer support." And one subscription buys one tutor, so a second tutor means a second 28-day clock, out of step with the first.
The price is per cycle rather than per hour, which cuts in your favour on duration.
At €10 a lesson the minimum plan is €40, and it buys either 4 lessons of 50 minutes or 8 of 25: "The total learning time stays the same." 200 minutes is 200 minutes.
The expiry is where it bites. A busy month with 4 lessons banked and 2 scheduled costs you the other 2, and neither comparison page says so plainly.
italki bills you per lesson and then stops
italki's model is the ordinary one. You buy a lesson, you take a lesson. Its own pricing guide: "There is no subscription, no monthly minimum, and no lock-in."
If you want to know what the most-quoted italki success statistic rests on, I read the source in my italki review.
The mechanics underneath get skipped everywhere. You're buying credits, and "credits are pegged to USD." The page says outright that "there is no pressure to buy in bulk."
Cancellation windows belong to each teacher, "typically 24 hours before the lesson."
italki Plus is separate and doesn't touch lesson pricing: "$5.99 per month, or $4.99 per month if you pay annually ($59.99 per year)." It generates summaries and flashcards from your sessions, worth knowing before you pay anyone else for that, including me.
Durations need care. italki's comparison page says you choose "30, 45, 60, or 90-minute sessions," which I'm attributing rather than stating, because the pricing guide is silent. Preply's 25 or 50 I can quote from the help centre.
Here's my honest gap. italki's comparison page says flatly that "credits do not expire." I couldn't confirm it anywhere I'd trust: the support site blocks curl, and the pricing guide is silent.
So I'm repeating neither that assurance nor the 12-month rule third-party sites quote. Ask italki support if a balance will sit for a year.
Per-lesson and per-hour prices are different units
italki's page compares "From $4 per lesson" against "From $10 per lesson for most tutors" on Preply. Two problems, both in italki's favour.
First, $4 is italki's community tutor floor. Its pricing page gives two bands: community tutors "typically charge between $4-$20 per lesson," professional teachers "$10-$40 per lesson." Preply's tutors mostly sit in the second band, so the fair comparison starts at $10.
Second, and worse: a per-lesson price and a per-hour price are different units. Every roundup I read subtracts one from the other anyway. Here's the conversion, which as far as I can tell none of them has done.
On 22 August 2026 I opened the first 21 Spanish tutors offering trial lessons on italki and wrote down every price. They were $5, $5, $6, $7, $7, $9, $10, $10, $10, $11, $12, $12, $12, $12, $15, $15, $17, $18, $18, $20, $25.
The 11th value, and so the median (the middle value), is $12. Put that $12 lesson through each duration italki lists:
One lesson price, a 3x spread in what an hour actually costs. That's why "from $4 per lesson" against "$16 per hour" compares nothing, and why the cheaper platform turns on a number neither company puts in the table.
Credit where it's due. This surprised me: Preply publishes better first-party numbers than italki does, and it isn't close.
Its Spanish rates page, updated 2 March 2026, gives a labelled table of averages by lesson type.
Speaking practice $16, beginners $17, Business Spanish $18, DELE prep $20, SIELE prep $21, against a stated range of $15 to $50. Dated, labelled, per hour. italki publishes bands.
Now the monthly floor. The cheapest way onto Preply is 4 lessons per 28 days at your tutor's rate: at the $16 speaking-practice average, about $53 a cycle, 13 cycles a year.
Four italki lessons at the median $12 is $48, bought whenever you want them.
Close on the sticker. Completely different on the risk, because two of those Preply lessons vanish if you don't get them onto a calendar in time.
Pick italki for an unpredictable schedule, Preply for commitment
So, back to the top. If your schedule is unpredictable, italki. A month where work eats you costs nothing there, and 2 lessons on a minimum Preply plan.
But the subscription is a commitment device, and those work on the people who need them. If you've quit tutoring twice because nobody was expecting you, an automatic charge attached to one named tutor does something a balance in an account cannot.
Preply's terms are better than its marketing, too. Booked lessons survive a renewal: "Any lessons you have already booked are fully protected and will take place as planned, regardless of when your renewal falls." Your rate is locked at signup and "will not increase without your acceptance."
Both good, and Preply's own comparison page barely mentions either.
Try 2 or 3 italki trials before committing anywhere. What you ask for in that first lesson changes the second more than the platform does.
One more thing before you pick either. Both sell you an hour and stop there.
italki says so itself: "It's up to you to take the language you learned in your italki lesson and add it to a smart platform." The vocabulary stays your problem, which is where the money leaks.
That gap is the thing I built. Verbamor is an iOS app that turns the words from a lesson you already paid for into fill-in-the-blank cards with native audio. They're scheduled so you're still using them next month.
It doesn't find you a tutor, and past about 650 starter words it teaches you nothing new. $19.99 a month, or $129.99 a year with a 7-day trial on the annual plan. No free tier, which is a real reason to skip it.
The honest version is that you might not need any of this. If you'll write your lesson words into a notebook on the train home and actually test yourself on them, that beats every app here including mine, and costs nothing.
Anki is free on desktop and Android and runs a serious scheduler. The people who should pay me have tried twice to keep a deck going and stopped.
Sources
How Preply bills you
- Preply Help Center (17 July 2026). How does my Preply subscription work? Source for the 28-day cycle, the 4-lesson minimum, expiry of unscheduled lessons, protection of booked lessons, the 20-day pause, the one-day cancellation window, the one-subscription-per-tutor rule, the drifting renewal date, the 1 January / 29 January / 26 February example, the €40 duration swap and its "total learning time stays the same" wording, the rate-change consent line, and the absence of one-time lesson purchases.
- Preply (2 March 2026). How much do Spanish lessons cost? First-party table labelled "Average Price on Preply," in dollars per hour, with a stated range of $15 to $50.
How italki bills you
- italki. italki pricing: complete pricing guide (2026). Source for the $4–$20 and $10–$40 per-lesson bands, italki Plus at $5.99 monthly or $59.99 annually with a 30-day free trial, credits pegged to USD with "no pressure to buy in bulk," the 30% to 50% trial discount, teacher-set packages, the typical 24-hour cancellation window, and the "no subscription, no monthly minimum, and no lock-in" line. It does not state lesson durations.
- italki. 3 ways to get more out of your italki lessons. Source for the quoted line about adding your lesson vocabulary to a review platform yourself.
- Spanish trial prices: my own observation of the first 21 Spanish tutors listing trial lessons on italki, 22 August 2026. All 21 are printed in the body above; the median is the 11th, $12. The hourly conversions in the table above are that median divided across the four durations, and the $53 monthly floor is 4 lessons of 50 minutes at Preply's published $16 speaking-practice average.
The pages this one is arguing with
- italki Language Learning Team (updated 2 June 2026). italki vs Preply: pricing, tutors, and flexibility compared (2026). Ranked first for both search phrasings on 22 August 2026. Also the only source I found for italki's 30, 45, 60 and 90-minute lesson lengths and for "credits do not expire," which is why both are attributed to it above rather than stated as fact. Measured at about 4,300 words, with an italki introduction of roughly 145 words against roughly 60 for Preply. Section boundaries are a judgement call, so treat both counts as approximate; the gap is not.
- Preply. italki and Preply review. Ranked second. Read in full on 22 August 2026: 3,567 words that never mention the 28-day cycle, the 4-lesson minimum, or the expiry of unscheduled lessons.
What I could not verify
- italki credit expiry. italki's comparison page asserts that "credits do not expire," but support.italki.com returns a challenge page to both automated fetching and curl, and italki's own pricing guide is silent on it. Neither that assurance nor the 12-month-inactivity rule circulating on third-party sites is treated as fact here.
- italki's "71.6% improved oral proficiency" figure, quoted on its own comparison page. No primary source reached, so it is not used above.
- Preply hourly rates outside the labelled Spanish table, and commission percentages for either platform. Third-party claims only.
Keep the words you already paid a tutor for.
Verbamor turns your lesson vocabulary into fill-in-the-blank cards with native audio, scheduled so they're still there next month.
Start 7 days freeThe 7-day free trial is on the yearly plan.